Active Under Contract
188 Days on market
58 Road To The Plains Edgartown — Photo 1 of 40

58 Road To The Plains Edgartown — Photo 1 of 40

Recent Drop: $70,000

$1,695,000
$1,625,000

$1,625,000

58 Road To The Plains, Edgartown, MA 02539

Edgartown, MA 02539

Beds

4

Baths

2

SqFt

1,342

Style

Single Family

Built

1981

Turnkey Katama Home—Beautifully furnished and move-in ready, this updated coastal retreat offers relaxed Island living with a strong rental history and effortless ownership. Outdoor highlights include a 19-foot heated swim spa and Jacuzzi set on an expansive wood deck, an outdoor shower, bluestone fire pit patio, multiple lounging spaces, decks, and wooded privacy for serene entertaining. Inside, the light-filled kitchen, living and dining area features cathedral ceilings, stainless steel appliances, granite countertops, and modern finishes. Recent improvements include a new roof, renovated bathroom, new maple flooring, refreshed interior, and updated landscaping. The thoughtful layout includes a primary bedroom with private balcony, two first-floor bedrooms with a shared full bath, and town sewer allowing expansion up to six bedrooms. Ideally located near South Beach and just minutes to Edgartown Village and Morning Glory Farm, this is a rare opportunity in a sought-after neighborhood

Market Value Analysis

This Property
Size (SqFt) →Price →
This Property$1211/sqft
Local Avg (Edgartown)$1267/sqft
4% BelowMarket Average

* Analysis is based on 24 actively listed and recently sold comparable properties strictly within Edgartown, MA.

Property Details

Financials

Original Price$1,695,000
Annual Taxes$2,881

Parking

Garage0
Off-Street5

Interior Specifications

Total Rooms6
FireplacesNone
FlooringTile, Hardwood
BasementNone

Climate & Utilities

HeatingHeat Pump
CoolingCentral Air
WaterPrivate
SewerPublic Sewer

Building & Exterior

ConstructionConventional (2x4-2x6)
RoofShingle
FoundationOther
ZoningR20

Property & Lot

Acres0.5
SqFt Lot21,780
Lot FeaturesWooded, Cleared, Level

Amenities & Appliances

Water Heater • Range • Dishwasher • Microwave • Refrigerator • Washer • Dryer

Neighborhood

Public Transportation • Shopping • Walk/Jog Trails • Bike Path

Geography

Floorplan Breakdown

Structural Layout

Second
Master BedroomBedroom 2Bathroom 2
Main,First
Living RoomDining RoomKitchenBedroom 3Bedroom 4Bathroom 1
Living Room
Lvl Main,First

Wood / Coal / Pellet Stove, Cathedral Ceiling(s), Ceiling Fan(s), Beamed Ceilings, Closet, Flooring - Hardwood, Window(s) - Picture, Deck - Exterior, Exterior Access, Lighting - Overhead

Dining Room
Lvl Main,First

Cathedral Ceiling(s), Beamed Ceilings, Flooring - Hardwood, Deck - Exterior, Exterior Access

Kitchen
Lvl Main,First

Flooring - Hardwood, Countertops - Stone/Granite/Solid, Kitchen Island, Deck - Exterior, Exterior Access, Gas Stove, Lighting - Overhead

Master Bedroom
Lvl Second

Bathroom - Full, Closet, Flooring - Hardwood, Balcony / Deck, Balcony - Exterior, Exterior Access, Slider

Bedroom 2
Lvl Second
Bedroom 3
Lvl Main,First

Closet, Flooring - Hardwood, Lighting - Overhead

Bedroom 4
Lvl Main,First

Closet, Flooring - Hardwood, Lighting - Overhead

Bathroom 1
Lvl Main,First

Bathroom - Full, Bathroom - Tiled With Tub & Shower, Flooring - Stone/Ceramic Tile, Countertops - Stone/Granite/Solid

Bathroom 2
Lvl Second

Bathroom - Full, Bathroom - Tiled With Shower Stall, Flooring - Stone/Ceramic Tile, Countertops - Stone/Granite/Solid, Lighting - Sconce

Property History

Price Drop
$1,625,000

Was $1,695,000

Jul 6, 2026

MLS® 73483009

Listed
$1,695,000

Mar 5, 2026

MLS® 73483009

Population

5,278

U.S. Census Bureau, ACS 2024 5-Year Estimates (B01003)

Median Household Income

$125K

U.S. Census Bureau, ACS 2024 5-Year Estimates (B19013)

Renter-Occupied Homes

13.0%

U.S. Census Bureau, ACS 2024 5-Year Estimates (B25003)

New Construction Permits — Dukes County

164 housing units permitted in the last 12 months (+80% vs the prior 12 months) — 35 in 5+ unit buildings

U.S. Census Bureau, Building Permits Survey (through Jun '26)

ADU Potential

Massachusetts allows one accessory dwelling unit by right in single-family zoning districts statewide (M.G.L. c. 40A §3; 760 CMR 71.00, effective Feb 2025). Estimated maximum ADU size for this property: 671 sq ft (the lesser of 900 sq ft or half the 1,342 sq ft principal dwelling). Lot size: 21,780 sq ft.

Based on listing data, which indicates the property type — not the zoning district. Local dimensional, septic (Title 5), and historic-district requirements still apply. Not legal advice — verify with the municipality.

Listing Provided By

Listing Agent: Stephanie Roache

Listing Office: Donnelly + Co.

MLS® Number: 73483009

Browse More Homes in Edgartown

Explore other active listings in the area.